Murphy Hollow’s $27 million land deduction denied
Murphy Hollow LLC, Piedmont Private Equity Manager LLC, Tax Matters Partner v. Commissioner. United States Tax Court. No. 9620-21. T.C. Memo. 2026-115.
Murphy Hollow gets zero for its land donation. Not only does the deduction vanish, but the IRS also slaps a 40% penalty for overvaluing the property and a 20% penalty on the remaining underpayment. Double whammy.
Holding
The Tax Court nuked Murphy Hollow’s $26.7 million deduction for 2017. The real value? $2.1 million, according to the Court. Anything claimed above that gets hit with a 40% penalty for gross overstatement. The remaining underpayment gets a 20% penalty for good measure.
Why It Matters
The decision separates two defects: an inflated value and a failure to obtain a qualified appraisal. The appraisal failure eliminates the whole deduction, including the portion equal to the property’s actual value.
The two penalty rates apply to different portions of an underpayment. The Court did not impose a combined 60% rate on the same tax or calculate penalties as a percentage of the donated land’s value.
The managers’ knowledge about the appraiser defeated both appraisal qualification and Murphy Hollow’s reasonable-cause defense to the 20% penalty. The statute separately bars that defense for the 40% charitable-property gross valuation penalty.
The Court applied existing appraisal and valuation principles. It did not establish a new restriction on charitable land gifts. The companion Hales Gap case shares this opinion but does not share Murphy Hollow’s additional 20% penalty.
