Tax Court upholds unreported wages but declines to review disputed $3,000 tax payment
Summer H. El Deeb v. Commissioner. United States Tax Court. No. 4398-24. T.C. Memo. 2026-101.
If you admit you got paid under the table, you’re on the hook for the tax bill—unless you can actually prove the money shouldn’t be taxed or there’s some legitimate offset. But here’s the catch: if you’re fighting with the IRS about estimated payments or credits from last year, the Tax Court won’t touch it in a deficiency case. Those don’t even enter the official math.
Holding
The Tax Court sided with the IRS: Summer H. El Deeb left $16,027 in wages off her 2021 tax return. No surprise there. As for the $3,000 credit she claimed from estimated payments or a 2020 carryover? The Court said, not our problem.
The IRS dropped its $1,000 penalty claim. Both sides hashed out the rest of the credits before and during trial. The Court punted the final math to Rule 155.
